Prepare a challenge to an arbitrator on the real danger of bias test
The responsible lawyer reviews the work against the instructions, sources and intended use.
You and the tool draft together, with you directing. You check every statement you rely on.
- Written for / version
- Western Australia versionAlso written for: Canada, Hong Kong SAR, India, Ireland, New Zealand, Singapore, South Africa, South Australia, United Kingdom (England and Wales), United States
What Green, Yellow and Red mean
- Green · Lawyer review
- The tool writes the first draft inside a template you have already tested. You check it. Without that test, first drafting starts at Yellow.
- Yellow · Close supervision
- You and the tool draft together, with you directing. You check every statement you rely on.
- Red · Lawyer-led
- You write the text. The tool writes nothing into the document.
The task in detail
Review and AI use
What the lawyer must review
Section 12(3) of the Commercial Arbitration Act 2012 (WA) allows a challenge only for justifiable doubts as to impartiality or independence, or for lack of agreed qualifications. Sections 12(5) and 12(6) say those doubts exist only if there is a real danger of bias. A party who appointed the arbitrator may challenge only for reasons that party became aware of after the appointment (section 12(4)).
Failing an agreed procedure, the written statement of reasons must be sent to the tribunal within 15 days (section 13(2)). If the challenge fails, a request to the Court must be made within 30 days after notice of the decision (section 13(4)). That request is an originating summons in Form 21 under rule 20 of the Supreme Court (Arbitration) Rules 2016.
A Court decision within its authority is final (section 13(5)).
How AI is used
List the disclosed circumstances, the date the party became aware of each, and the date the tribunal was constituted. Draft the challenge only from facts the lawyer has marked.
Who does what
Who does what
| Role | What they do |
|---|---|
| Assistance | Potential support includes preparing preliminary structure or wording. Confirm the tool’s capability and permitted scope. |
| Lawyer | Set the scope, supervise the work closely, verify every part relied on, resolve omissions and exceptions, and approve the exact output. |
Checklist
Checklist
- Open each relied-on authority independently. Confirm its existence, current status, proposition and any quotation or pinpoint reference.
- Confirm the output against the client’s instructions and the complete relevant source material, including omissions or contradictions.
- Resolve exceptions and record the responsible lawyer’s approval of the exact output and intended use.
Rules that apply
Rules that apply
The document starts from the task name. Change it if this piece of work is different.
Name the court or tribunal, or say that no court is involved. Court notes are not listed until you do.
More detail: 18 professional guidance items, 16 notes without a stated scopeExpand for more
Professional guidance
These guide the profession. They are not a rule of the court or tribunal.
| Instrument | Rank | Why it applies | What it requires |
|---|---|---|---|
| AI guidance to safeguard consumers of legal services - LPBWA | Professional guidance | It guides barristers and lawyers (WA). Stored summary: “News item dated 6 December 2024. The Legal Practice Board of Western Australia, with the Law Society of New South Wales and the Victorian Legal Services Board and Commissioner, announced the joint statement. The page says the statement applies to solicitors in NSW and to solicitors and barristers in Victoria and WA, and is based on the ethical conduct rules. It says the ethical standards in the Legal Profession Uniform Law and conduct rules apply equally to the use of AI. Duties named on this page: maintain client confidentiality; provide independent advice; be honest and deliver legal services competently and diligently; charge costs that are fair, reasonable and proportionate. Lawyers using AI should consider clear risk-based policies to minimise data and security breaches; limit AI to lower-risk tasks, with the page's example of an initial draft of an email, and not use it for higher-risk tasks, with the page's example of translating legal advice into another language; and be transparent, disclosing to clients and the court when and how the technology was used where necessary or mandated by the rules of court. The full statement is linked from the page. This row is the Board's news item, not a substitute for that statement.” |
|
| AI hub: Responsible and ethical use of AI | Professional guidance | It guides lawyers (WA). Stored summary: “A Law Society of Western Australia AI hub page. It lists ways AI can support lawyers, such as summarising, first drafts, research, transcription and proofreading. It names three risk areas: inaccurate output and hallucinations, threats to confidentiality and privacy, and copyright infringement. It says AI-generated material may have serious errors or complete fabrications, and that practitioners need to educate themselves and their staff and take reasonable steps to put safeguards in place. It then lists resources: ethical guidance from the Law Council of Australia, the Queensland Law Society, the Law Institute of Victoria and the Law Society of NSW; Law Society Brief articles; and material on AI misuse.” |
|
| AI hub: submissions and advocacy | Professional guidance | It guides lawyers (WA). Stored summary: “The Law Society's AI advocacy page. It says the Society advocates non-prescriptive court guidance and has made submissions to the Supreme Court of Western Australia and the Federal Court of Australia. The submission PDFs linked on the page use a staging host and were not opened. A separate letter dated 29 October 2025, from the President to the Chief Justice of the Federal Court, was read: it responds to a proposed Federal Court litigants-in-person practice note and recommends that the note include published guidance for litigants in person on artificial intelligence in Federal Court proceedings. That letter is about a federal court, not a Western Australian rule.” | The stored text does not state a specific check. |
| AI selection and use checklist (joint initiative) | Professional guidance | It guides lawyers (QLD, VIC, SA, WA, ACT, NT, TAS). Stored summary: “Multi-society risk-assessment checklist for selecting and using AI tools.” |
|
| AI selection and use checklist for legal practitioners (February 2026) | Professional guidance | It guides lawyers (WA, QLD). Stored summary: “A February 2026 checklist for small and mid-tier firms selecting a third-party AI tool. The cover says it is a joint initiative by the Queensland Law Society in collaboration with the Law Institute of Victoria, the Law Society of South Australia, the Law Society of Western Australia, the Law Society of the Australian Capital Territory, the Law Society Northern Territory and the Law Society of Tasmania. The Law Society of Western Australia hosts a public copy and links it from its risk page. It is a risk tool, not a Western Australian conduct rule. The copy read is the public lawsocietywa.asn.au file, not the staging link shown on the risk page.” |
|
| Artificial Intelligence (AI) and the Future of Law | Professional guidance | It guides lawyers (WA). Stored summary: “Law Society of Western Australia publishes “Artificial Intelligence (AI) and the Future of Law”. AI can perform complex tasks that once required human input. One part of this article was written by a lawyer and the other part generated by ChatGPT. Can you tell the difference? Checked 2026-10-10. Read the linked page before relying on it.” | The stored text does not state a specific check. |
| Artificial Intelligence and the Legal Profession | Professional guidance | It guides lawyers (AU). Stored summary: “Law Council portal, last updated on the page as 03/09/2025, maintained as a Futures Committee collection of constituent-body material. It is not itself a conduct ruling. The page says some material may become outdated and practitioners should confirm the current guidance in their own jurisdiction. Improper use may carry ethical, professional and legal risks. As recorded on this page: the Law Institute of Victoria has an Ethical and Responsible Use of AI guidance note, an AI Action Group, CPD and a technology masterclass, and an AI fact sheet still in development; the Law Society of the ACT hosted CPD in March 2025 (AI essentials for sole practitioners and small firms, legal-specific AI tools, and responsible practice covering ethics and risk) and published the 2024 Blackburn Lecture in Ethos; the Law Society of New South Wales lists a solicitor's guide, an AI glossary, court protocols, the Uniform Law statement and CPD; the Law Society of Western Australia is developing draft AI resources which, once finalised, will be published on the portal; the New South Wales Bar Association published guidelines in July 2023 on AI language models including ChatGPT and intends to update them; the Queensland Law Society lists its guidance statement, companion guide and template AI use policy.” | The stored text does not state a specific check. |
| Artificial intelligence hub | Professional guidance | It guides lawyers (WA). Stored summary: “The Law Society of Western Australia's public artificial intelligence hub. The page says it brings together commentary, court directions, risk resources, and the Society's advocacy and policy positions. It is an index. It is not itself a conduct rule. No date is printed on the page.” | The stored text does not state a specific check. |
| Generative AI and Ethical Considerations in Legal Practice | Professional guidance | It guides lawyers (WA). Stored summary: “Law Society of WA brief and AI Hub; separate brief on copyright and generative AI.” | The stored text does not state a specific check. |
| Lawyers' ethics and the use of artificial intelligence in legal services (Brief, April 2023) | Professional guidance | It guides lawyers (WA). Stored summary: “A Brief article hosted by the Law Society of Western Australia. The footer date is April 2023. It discusses competence, confidentiality, privilege, independence and generative AI, and argues that the general competence duty may include competence with technology where Western Australia has no specific technology commentary. It is commentary. It is not a conduct ruling of the Law Society or the Legal Practice Board.” |
|
| New AI guidelines provide clarity, but disclosure catch-all causes concern (Brief, 21 November 2025) | Professional guidance | It guides lawyers (WA). Stored summary: “A Brief article on the Supreme Court of Western Australia's generative AI guidelines. It says the Law Society made a submission in April 2025 urging "flexible, principles-based guidance, rather than a proscriptive practice direction", and welcomes the Court's approach. It reports a Law Society survey in which more than half of respondents used AI tools in everyday practice. It summarises the guidelines' duties on verification, responsibility for filed documents, affidavits and witness statements, and expert reports. It says the final direction, that AI use "should be disclosed" when directed by the court "or where otherwise necessary or appropriate", creates uncertainty without a procedural direction, especially for self-represented litigants. The article is commentary, not a rule.” |
|
| Risk alert: AI and increasing risk factors for legal practitioners (Brief, 8 October 2026) | Professional guidance | It guides barristers and lawyers (WA). Stored summary: “A risk alert in Brief by Jehan-Philippe Wood and Jonathan Edgelow. It says courts and clients now expect practitioners to use AI, which raises risk factors for solicitors and barristers. It names overconfidence and failure to supervise, verify AI outputs and apply professional judgement as key risks. It lists the areas of professional standards most engaged: confidentiality and privilege, competence and diligence, duties to the court, and fair and proportionate costs. It notes that courts have referred lawyers to conduct authorities, made adverse costs orders and issued warnings over AI misuse, and that negligence claims by clients are a further risk. The article is commentary, not a rule.” |
|
| Risk management for legal practices, including Ethics Committee questions on AI | Professional guidance | It guides lawyers (WA). Stored summary: “Law Society page encouraging law practices to adopt AI policies and training, and setting out questions prepared by the Society's Ethics Committee. It encourages policies that include client consent before AI is used to record, transcribe, summarise or draft client-related documents. It is professional guidance. It does not say that client consent is required before every use of AI, and it does not amend the Australian Solicitors' Conduct Rules.” |
|
| The Impact of Social Media and AI on Public Trust in the Judiciary (Global Summit of Hellenic Lawyers, Athens) | Professional guidance | It guides lawyers (WA). Stored summary: “A speech by the Chief Justice of Western Australia on social media, artificial intelligence and trust in the courts. He asks what the legal tradition offers in response to AI in the legal process. His answer is the common law's preference for orality, in both oral evidence and oral advocacy. He says that in Western Australia a procedure using written witness statements as evidence in civil cases was replaced with a return to oral evidence, because of judicial disquiet about the authenticity of written evidence. He says the challenges AI poses are new, but the underlying concerns are the same: authenticity, intelligibility and immediacy. The speech is not a rule or practice direction.” | The stored text does not state a specific check. |
| Using AI: your questions answered | Professional guidance | It guides lawyers (WA). Stored summary: “Educational questions and answers published by the Law Society of Western Australia on its AI hub. The page says they are for information and are not a substitute for legal advice. It records views of the Society's Ethics Committee on policies, training, and not using an AI program the lawyer cannot explain. It points lawyers to the Legal Practice Board joint statement, the Australian Solicitors' Conduct Rules, and the Supreme Court guidelines on disclosure. It does not create a new conduct rule.” |
|
| Copyright and generative artificial intelligence | Secondary | It guides lawyers (WA). Stored summary: “Law Society of Western Australia publishes “Copyright and generative artificial intelligence”. Checked 2026-10-10. Read the linked page before relying on it.” The stored source is secondary. Read the primary text before you rely on it. | The stored text does not state a specific check. |
| Statement on the use of AI in Australian legal practice (adopted) | Secondary | It guides lawyers (WA). Stored summary: “LPBWA publishes the Uniform Law regulators' joint AI statement for WA practitioners.” The stored source is secondary. Read the primary text before you rely on it. | The stored text does not state a specific check. |
| What is AI? — Law Society of Western Australia | Secondary | It guides lawyers (WA). Stored summary: “Law Society of Western Australia publishes “What is AI? — Law Society of Western Australia”. Checked 2026-10-10. Read the linked page before relying on it.” The stored source is secondary. Read the primary text before you rely on it. | The stored text does not state a specific check. |
Scope not stated
These stored notes do not say who they cover, so they are not applied.
- Artificial intelligence frequently asked questions
- GSA v Department of Communities [No 2] [2026] WASCA 36: a judge's criticism of AI-sourced text and request to disclose the source did not show bias
- Generative AI tools developed for internal government use
- WA Government Artificial Intelligence Advisory Board terms of reference
- Hutchinson v Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd [2026] WASC 128: pleading struck out as incoherent; the plaintiff acknowledged using ChatGPT
- Cokic v Aquilina [2025] WADC 44: claim that a court transcript was generated by artificial intelligence rejected
- Artificial Intelligence governance toolkit for WA public sector entities
- Brendon Hill v Director General, Department of Education, 2026 WAIRC 00748: directions requiring all filed material to comply with Practice Note 1 of 2026 (use of artificial intelligence)
- What the Machine Doesn't Know: Humanity, Artificial Intelligence and the Law (Minds Count Annual Lecture 2026)
- Privacy and Responsible Information Sharing Act 2024, automated decision-making and IPP 10
- Report 95: Terms of reference, inquiry into artificial intelligence in Western Australia
- News: new practice notes, including Practice Note 1 of 2026 on use of AI
- LPBWA - Resources - Legal Practice Board of Western Australia
- Artificial Intelligence (AI) and Privacy | Legal Aid WA
- April 2026 Generative Artificial Intelligence Practice Note (GPN-AI)
- Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia releases Practice Direction on the use of Artificial Intelligence
Forms and precedents
Forms and precedents for this task
| Form or precedent | Kind | AI use | Summary |
|---|---|---|---|
| Notice challenging an arbitrator under section 13 (South Australia) | Notice | AI use Yellow | A written statement of reasons for challenging an arbitrator in a South Australian domestic arbitration, within the 15 day period. |
Signed-in accounts can read the full text of each one. All precedents.