---
title: "Defence and counterclaim in a High Court commercial contract claim"
url: "https://ailawframework.com/precedents/commercial-litigation-and-dispute-resolution/ie-defence-and-counterclaim"
type: "precedent"
site: "AI Law Framework"
id: "a5-ie-defence-and-counterclaim"
area_id: "A5"
kind: "court-document"
ai_level: "yellow"
version: 1
task_ids: ["A5-T1-R2", "A5-A20260923-1", "A5-T1-R15"]
law_stated_as_at: "2026-11-12"
---

# Defence and counterclaim in a High Court commercial contract claim

> A High Court defence for a commercial contract claim, with a counterclaim if one is instructed, the eight-week time, and the ban on a bare denial of a debt.

Canonical page: https://ailawframework.com/precedents/commercial-litigation-and-dispute-resolution/ie-defence-and-counterclaim  
Law stated as at: 2026-11-12

Site index for agents: https://ailawframework.com/llms.txt

## Key facts

- Kind: Court document. A document filed or served in a court or tribunal.
- Practice area: [Commercial Litigation & Dispute Resolution](https://ailawframework.com/precedents/commercial-litigation-and-dispute-resolution.md)
- Jurisdictions: Ireland
- AI level: Yellow. You and the tool draft together, with you directing. You check every statement you rely on.
- Law stated as at: 2026-11-12
- Status: Maintained. Checked on 2026-11-12 against the 3 authorities it cites, for Ireland.

## When to use it

Use when a defendant has entered an appearance to a plenary summons in a commercial contract claim and must deliver a defence. Do not use it as a replying affidavit on a summary summons. Do not use it for a personal injuries defence, which has its own form.

## Used for these tasks

- [Draft pleadings from the facts-and-issues brief](https://ailawframework.com/practice/commercial-litigation-and-dispute-resolution/draft-pleadings-from-the-facts-and-issues-brief.md)
- [Summarise the opposing pleading and list the facts still in issue](https://ailawframework.com/practice/commercial-litigation-and-dispute-resolution/summarise-the-opposing-pleading-and-list-the-facts-still-in-issue.md)
- [Build a limitation and procedural-deadline calendar from the file](https://ailawframework.com/practice/commercial-litigation-and-dispute-resolution/build-a-limitation-and-procedural-deadline-calendar-from-the-file.md)

## How AI may be used

The tool may set out each paragraph of the statement of claim with a draft admission or non-admission from the defendant's instructions, and the solicitor decides every response.

**AI may:**

- Place each paragraph of the statement of claim beside a draft response taken from an approved note
- List allegations that the draft neither admits nor denies
- Flag a debt claim that the draft answers only with the words 'denied'

**AI must not:**

- Must not admit a paragraph the defendant has not instructed
- Must not plead a limitation defence, a release, or fraud unless the instructions and the documents support that plea
- Must not deliver the defence

**The lawyer checks:**

- Every allegation is admitted, not admitted, or denied in substance, except damages
- A debt is not met by a mere denial, and a contract is not met by a bare denial if the point is a point of law
- The defence is delivered inside the eight weeks in Order 21, rule 1, or inside any Commercial List direction that replaces it

## Authorities

- [Rules of the Superior Courts, Order 21, rules 1, 3, 5, 6 and 9 (time, debt, denial, damages, and counterclaim)](https://www.courts.ie/court-rules/full-court-rule?url=Order-21-Superior-Defence-and-Counterclaim)
- [Rules of the Superior Courts, Order 19, rules 13, 15, 17, 19 and 20 (admissions, surprise, specific denial, and a bare denial of a contract)](https://www.courts.ie/court-rules/full-court-rule?url=Order-19-Superior-Pleading-Generally)
- [Statute of Limitations 1957, s 11 (plea of limitation)](https://revisedacts.lawreform.ie/eli/1957/act/6/section/11/revised/en/html)

## Full text and drafting notes

The full text and the drafting notes are not part of this public page. Signed-in firm accounts can read them at https://ailawframework.com/precedents/commercial-litigation-and-dispute-resolution/ie-defence-and-counterclaim and through the signed-in MCP connector https://ailawframework.com/mcp/firm.

*Practice guidance for planning and review. Confirm current primary sources and the requirements of the actual matter. This is general information, not legal advice.*
