---
title: "Say where issues that are not common will be decided"
url: "https://ailawframework.com/practice/class-actions-representative-proceedings/advise-where-claims-that-are-not-common-will-be-decided/south-africa"
type: "task_jurisdiction_version"
site: "AI Law Framework"
id: "A7-LA20261022-10-ZA"
practice_area: "Class Actions / Representative Proceedings"
tier: "red"
lawyer_review: "required"
jurisdictions: ["ZA"]
last_reviewed: "2026-11-12"
last_checked: "2026-11-12"
---

# Say where issues that are not common will be decided

> Split the pleaded issues into common issues and issues personal to each member, with the stage the draft order gives to each. Do not advise where a member's own damages will be decided.

Canonical page: https://ailawframework.com/practice/class-actions-representative-proceedings/advise-where-claims-that-are-not-common-will-be-decided/south-africa  
Last checked: 2026-11-12

Site index for agents: https://ailawframework.com/llms.txt

## Key facts

| Fact | Value |
| --- | --- |
| Practice area | [Class Actions / Representative Proceedings](https://ailawframework.com/practice/class-actions-representative-proceedings.md) |
| Human involvement | Red: Lawyer writes; AI may check, clarify or collect data |
| How AI is used | Split the pleaded issues into common issues and issues personal to each member, with the stage the draft order gives to each. Do not advise where a member's own damages will be decided. |
| What the lawyer must review | The attorney advises. Children's Resource Centre at paragraph 26 says a class action may be certified on limited issues, such as negligence in a mass injury claim, leaving damages to be decided separately. Paragraph 45 says the action need not dispose of every part of the claim. Common issues may be certified for the whole class and other issues for a sub-class. The test is whether the common issues will dispose of all or a significant part of the claims. Nkala certified a first stage for the common issues and a second stage for the individual issues, with opt-in at the second stage. That split served the interests of justice in that case. It is not required in every class action. |
| Written for | South Africa |
| Applies to | [Advise where claims that are not common will be decided](https://ailawframework.com/practice/class-actions-representative-proceedings/advise-where-claims-that-are-not-common-will-be-decided.md) |

## Checking plan

- What the AI does: Split the pleaded issues into common issues and issues personal to each member, with the stage the draft order gives to each. Do not advise where a member's own damages will be decided.
- Basis: Checked against the linked sources on 12 November 2026. Confirm the current instrument before reliance.

## Notes

- Success on a common issue does not by itself pay a member's claim. Causation and the amount often remain for a later stage.
- A sub-class can be certified for a subsidiary issue. Map it before the common hearing closes.
- Nkala said individual defences can be raised at the appropriate stage, including by an amendment to the plea. Do not assume every defence must be pleaded before the common stage.

## Sources

- [Children's Resource Centre Trust v Pioneer Food (Pty) Ltd 2012 ZASCA 182 (SAFLII), paragraphs 26 and 45](https://www.saflii.org/za/cases/ZASCA/2012/182.html) (checked 2026-11-12)
- [Nkala and Others v Harmony Gold Mining Company Limited and Others 2016 ZAGPJHC 97, paragraphs 116 to 121 and 173](https://www.saflii.org/za/cases/ZAGPJHC/2016/97.html) (checked 2026-11-12)

*Practice guidance for planning and review. Confirm current primary sources and the requirements of the actual matter. This is general information, not legal advice.*
